Emily, an Englischer, has just lost her mother. Now she must go live with the father she never knew - an Amish man. It turns out he didn't know Emily existed either.
As if trying to adopt to the Amish way isn’t hard enough, Emily’s father and his family struggle to accept her. However, she meets Caleb, the handsome Amish employee at the restaurant her new family runs. She's drawn to Caleb’s gentle demeanor and strong faith, and soon can’t help but to fall in love with him. Caleb, meanwhile, has also developed feelings for Emily. But there's a problem...he's a baptized Amish young man, and Emily is an Englischer. Both hearts are troubled now. Is it possible that Emily and Caleb can somehow find love and happiness?
Then an opportunity arises for Emily to return to her Englisch world with an unexpected visit. Now Emily is torn and must make a choice. How will God work amidst this difficult dilemma?