The storm swept through and wrecked Second Chance Farm and with it Emily’s heart. Jordan’s horse Wizard is missing and no one knows where he is. They’ve searched high and low and they can’t find him anywhere. Emily suspects he’s been stolen. Jordan thinks that the horse might be trying to make his way back home and Taylor thinks she might just sue Emily and her father.
On top of that the next team show in the Junior Olympic series is fast approaching and with it Valentine's Day. Emily had thought that maybe Jordan would ask her out. Now she thinks that he just hates her because she lost his horse. And even though Bluebird is in top form, Emily isn’t feeling her best. She can’t shake the cold she caught in the storm and she’s worried that if she doesn’t get better, she might have to miss the show altogether and forfeit her place on the team.
And it's not just Wizard that Emily is trying to find. There is another horse. One she used to ride and now can’t get out of her mind. The first horse she fell in love with. But can it really be possible that Harlow is out there competing again after Esther retired him? And if he is, why is it that he is sound and winning when his vets had resigned him to a life of lameness as a pasture pet?