When Ettie stumbles across some bones in a field, the local detective believes she knows the truth behind the man's murder. In her efforts to prove to him that she knows nothing, Ettie is led to Amish woman, Gertie, and her menacing neighbor. Gertie shares with them a shocking tale of two other murders that were deemed 'accidents.' Ettie dismisses the story as nothing more than Gertie's vivid imagination until Gertie goes missing.