Skye, Chad, and Morgan are preparing for another summer of teaching special needs children how to ride the horses at Keystone Stables. One student, Joey Klingerman, has Down syndrome, and is very outgoing and talkative to everyone he meets. Almost immediately, Joey takes a special liking to Skye, constantly calling her his girlfriend. Embarrassed and furious, Skye begins to treat Joey harshly when the Chambers aren’t around. Joey has been training hard for the Snyder County Fair, but when his horse comes up lame, Skye is forced to make a big decision; will she continue to treat him badly, or show him God’s love?