The marriage of Jennifer and Darren has lost its magic. What was once a beautiful relationship is slowly being destroyed by their petty arguments and stubborn behavior. On Christmas Eve, a mall Santa Claus asks them separately what gift they would like to receive and they both wish for a perfect spouse. In the morning, both wake up and see their wish has been granted. Jennifer finds that her new husband is rich, caring and likes her mother. Darren learns that in his new life he has opened his own business and lives with his loving supermodel wife. The big shock for Darren and Jennifer is that their houses are next to each other and now they are neighbors. Learn what happens when an imperfect couple is faced with living different lives with their ideal mates and the realization that they may never be able to get their true love back.