First we have to get something off our chest: The twist-up applicator feels like a freaky game of Russian Roulette or Jack in a Box as you twist and twist, anxiously awaiting the creamy formula to appear on the fuzzy tip. Phew. But once it finally does dispense, the formula is as soft and creamy as they come. The rounded tip makes it easy to apply under the eye area, camouflaging any traces of darkness and minor imperfections, without a hint of cakiness. You'll want to use your finger to blend it in, as the tip tends to continue distributing more product-possibly because of our overzealous twisting, but nonetheless, fingers are best to smooth it all out. You'll want to continue using an everyday eye cream for anti-aging, but we were pleasantly surprised with its ability to depuff tired eyes. And with a formula this creamy, with absolutely zero crepiness, we definitely looked a few days younger, even if it did wash off before bed. One caveat: The two-shade range can be limiting. The shades include light and medium, both of which are quite fair.